Automation World recently covered a digital twin application for virtual commissioning in an article detailing Burr Oak Tool’s use of the technology to reduce time to market for its equipment and to train tool operators. More recently, we learned that JR Automation, a supplier of intelligent automated manufacturing and distribution technologies, is using digital twin technology to virtually commission a robotic cell developed for material handling applications.
At the 2019 Siemens Automation Summit, JR Automation’s Matt Cagle, engineering manager, and Marc Walters, senior controls engineer, described their development of a patent-pending robotic flexible sortation system (RFSS) prototype using digital twin technology. The RFSS incorporates a Fanuc R2000-iC/165F robot, as well as proximity sensors, reed sensors, and photoelectric sensors (more than 25 of which were simulated in the digital twin). It also includes a Siemens S7-1515F programmable logic controller (PLC), and a Siemens TP1200 Comfort human machine interface (HMI). Software used to develop and simulate the RFSS included Siemens TIA Portal v15.1, Siemens Simatic PLCSim Advanced, and Siemens Process Simulate solutions.
Up to 1,500 sorts per hour
The target application for the RFSS is essentially any operation that sorts product, said Cagle. Potential customers include e-commerce companies, like Amazon and Walmart, as well as users in the automotive, defense, and aerospace industries who employ kitting, sequencing, and kit assembly operations.
Cagle pointed out that each robot in the RFSS is capable of 500 sorts per hour and that the RFSS is designed to allow up to three robots to be placed in series and controlled by one PLC, yielding a throughput of 1,500 sorts per hour. “Common sortation systems capable of 10,500 sorts per hour typically occupy approximately 25,000 sq. ft.," he said. "But the RFSS system is capable of the same number of sorts while occupying only 12,500 sq. ft.”
“The design of the RFSS also limits down time due to maintenance activities,” Cagle added. “During maintenance on a multi-robot RFSS, a single robot can be bypassed while the others continue to run.”
Real-world discoveries
“During development, we quickly found value in the virtual commissioning process, as we discovered mechanical interference and programming issues we would not have seen prior to building out the system without virtual commissioning,” said Cagle.
The typical development process for this kind of robotic cell involves programming and mechanical design teams working together, according to Cagle. But this collaboration doesn’t tend to happen until those teams are on the shop floor physically building the system. “With early virtual commissioning, you can see if the locations where you’re expecting to mount devices may be wrong—or the space needed for those devices may be missing,” he said. “Virtual commissioning provides early feedback to mechanical personnel, so they don’t have to scrap real world designs later.”
He added that having the ability to visualize the complete system in advance of the build means that the customer can also have input to improve the design and help highlight potential safety issues.
Applied technologies
JR Automation built their simulations of the robotic cell in TIA Portal, using Siemens Simatic S7-PLCSim Advanced to incorporate real world PLC and HMI data. With this combination of software, “we’re not just simulating a robot, we're bringing all the real-world devices in the system into the 3D world,” said Walters. This allows for complete virtual debugging of the devices. “Robot manufacturers have simulation tools for their robots, but nothing around it," , he said. "PLCSim Advanced brings all this together.”
Using TIA Portal with PLCSim Advanced, you can communicate with the simulated environment and the hardware on the floor, Walters explained. “This software brings robots, PLCs, and HMIs together so that you can see all interlocks and handshake signals to determine if anything is missing. For us, the digital twin means that we can run an entire virtual material handling system on a PC. The PLC dictates how the robot handles materials and we can verify it in PLCSim Advanced. Then we use PLCSim Advanced to simulate the HMI in remote mode for debugging and commissioning.”
Walters added that JR Automation also uses Siemens Process Simulate to create digital scenarios with multiple machines, robots, conveyors, and sensors. With Process Simulate, you can verify reach and cycle times, and do event-based simulations. Having the ability to do this in one environment means that there’s no need to know multiple software or robot packages. "It’s robot agnostic and shines with multiple robots,” Walters said.
As with the Burr Oak Tools virtual commissioning application referenced above, a key aspect of this JR Automation project is the high-speed PLC connection to the simulation.
“OPC communications are too slow to connect virtual PLCs and simulation,” said Walters, as they are in the 300-500 millisecond range. But the communication pipe connecting the virtual model and the virtual PLC in PLCSim Advanced allows for synchronized communications in the 15-20 millisecond range.
Return on investment
Cagle said they know they saved weeks of debugging time with this combination of software, but total ROI (return on investment) remains to be determined. “This is the first project we’ve done with this and we just completed it in April,” he said.
Beyond initial ROI, another benefit Cagle highlighted is the ability for JR Automation to use this software to train users on use of the system. “In this virtual world, people can push buttons and try things to see what happens,” he said. “Also, we can make faults happen in the virtual world to train users on how to effectively recover from them.”
